Introduction

Probably most realize that the story of Yeshua’s arrest, trial, crucifixion, burial and resurrection is probably an enigma of sorts.  The Apostle Paul wrote in I Corinthians 15:12-19 the following: “Now if Christ is preached that He has been raised from the dead, how do some among you say that there is no resurrection of the dead?  But if there is no resurrection of the dead, then Christ is not risen.  And if Christ is not risen, then our preaching is vain and your faith is also vain.  Yes, and we are fou8nd false witnesses of God, because we have testified of God that He raised up Christ, whom He did not raise up – if in fact the dead do not rise.  For if the dead do not rise, then Christ is not risen.  And if Christ is not risen, your faith is futile; you are still in your sins!  Then also those who have fallen asleep in Christ have perished.  If in this life only we have hope in Christ, we are of all men the most pitiable.”  Pure and simple, these verses means that our hope for the future lies completely on the fact that Yeshua the Messiah was resurrected from the dead and so will we.

The purpose of this book is not to cast any doubts on the death, burial and resurrection of Yeshua the Messiah.  We affirm that truth with all the faith and truth that is humanly possible.  The situation that we want to look at in depth is the trial of Yeshua before the Sanhedrin before His death, burial and resurrection.  What most people do not realize is that if the Sanhedrin had followed their laws, both Written Torah and Oral Torah, as they should have, the crucifixion probably would not have happened.  That may sound a little crazy, but bear with me as we look at His trial verse by verse as it progressed from His arrest to His appearance before Pontius Pilate.  I have listed at least twenty-four violations of the law committed by members of the Sanhedrin during Yeshua’s trial.  Had these laws been obeyed as they should have, Yeshua would have been declared innocent of any charges and set free.  But He had to go to the cross.  If He didn’t, we would have absolutely no hope in the life to come.  That is the enigma.  If the Jews hadn’t disobeyed their laws, Yeshua wouldn’t have went to the cross.  But sine they did disobey their laws, He did go to the cross and we are the benefactors of it.

We will first give the verse(s) from the New Testament with a commentary, and then the law that was violate, either from th Old Testament or the Mishnah (Oral Law) or both.  The Mishnah reference will be identified as M:Sanhedrin X:X for example.

Violation No. 1

The trial was to be held before impartial judges.  The judges Yeshua’s trial hated Him.  They did not know yet how they would carry their plan out, but they were determined to do so.

Exodus 23:2
You shall not follow a crowd to do evil; nor shall you testify in a dispute so as
to turn aside after many to pervert justice.

Deuteronomy 16:18, 19
You shall appoint judges and officers in all your gates, which the Lord your
God gives you, according to your tribes; and they shall judge the people with
just judgment.

Matthew 26:15
What are you willing to give me if I deliver Him to you?  And they
counted out to him thirty pieces of silver.

Violation No. 2

:Judas was bribed with thirty pieces of silver.  The law stated that there was to be no proceedings conducted by ecclesiastical authorities which was affected by a bribe.  With this second violation, the whole thing should have come to a screeching halt and not gone any further.  Giving Judas a bribe should have stopped the whole thing right then.

Deuteronomy 16:19
You shall not pervert justice; you shall not show partiality, not take
a bribe, for a bribe blinds the eyes of the wise and twists the words
of the righteous.

M:Berachoth 4:6
If one take payment to act as a judge to give legal decisions, his judgments are void; if he accept payment to give evidence, his testimony is void.

Matthew 26:59, 60
Now the chief priests, the elders, and all the council sought false testimony
against Jesus to put Him to death, but found none.  Even though many false
witnesses came forward, they found none.

Mark 14:57
Then some rose up and bore false witness against Him, saying ......”

Violation No. 3

Known false witnesses were allowed to testify.  The ninth commandment God wrote with His own finger state, “You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor” (Exodus 20:16).  Yet known false witness were sought after and used during Yeshua’s trial.  Not only didn’t the judges make any attempt to ascertain if the witnesses were telling the truth, they didn’t have to because they knew in advance that they were lying.

Notice also the commandment says that if the witness is caught lying, he is to suffer the same fate as the person he was lying on.  And since Caiaphas and the other judges knew that they were lying, they would be guilty of the same consequence as the false witnesses.

Deuteronomy 19:16-19, 21
If a false witness rises against any man to testify against him of wrongdoing,
then both men in the controversy shall stand before the Lord, before the priests
and the judges who serve in those days.

And the judges shall make careful inquiry, and indeed, if the witness is a false
witness, who has testified falsely against his brother, then you shall do to him
as he thought to have done to his brother, so you shall put away the evil from
among you.

Mark 14:59
But not even then did their testimony agree.

Violation No. 4

Before testifying, the witness must solemnly promise to tell the truth.  Since these were all false witnesses, this was impossible.

M:Sanhedrin 4:5
The judge shall address each witness as follows: it is not conjecture,
or anything you may have heard, that we ask you ..... if you should
cause the accused to be condemned unjustly, his blood shall cry for
vengeance against you, and God will hold you accountable, even as
He did Cain for the blood of his brother Abel.

Matthew 26:59
Now the chief priests, the elders, and all the council sought false testimony against Jesus to put Him to death.

Violation No. 5

Merits of Yeshua’s defense were not investigated.  No investigation by the court was initiated to determine the merits of any accusations against Yeshua.  The council had already found Him guilty before the trial had even started.  He had no defense to present as far as they were concerned.

Deuteronomy 19:16-18
If a false witness rises against any man to testify against him of
wrongdoing, then both men in the controversy will stand before
the Lord, before the priests and the judges who serve in those days.
And the judges shall make careful inquiry .....

M:Sanhedrin 5:1
They used to examine them (the witnesses) with seven inquiries:

Violation No. 6

No testimony of a witness is valid unless the witnesses all agree in each detail.  The Sanhedrin could not find witnesses that had the same story.  It is ironic that they would follow this part of the law and ignore so much of the rest of it.

M:Sanhedrin 5:2
If one witness contradicts another, the testimony is not accepted.

Matthew 26:62-65
And the high priest arose and said to Him, “Do you answer nothing?
What is it these men testify against you?”  But Jesus kept silent.  And
the high priest answered and said to Him, “I put You under oath by the
living God: tell us if You are the Christ, the Son of God!”

Jesus said to him, “It is as you said .....”

Then the high priest tore his clothes, saying, “He has spoken blasphemy!
What further need do we have of witnesses?”

Violation No. 7

The judges used Yeshua’s own testimony to condemn Him.  According to Jewish Law a person could not be condemned based on their own testimony (self-incrimination).

Deuteronomy 19:15
One witness shall not rise against a man concerning any inquiry
or any sin that he commits; by the mouth of two or three witnesses
the matter shall be established.

Maimonides, Sanhedrin 6:2
We have it as a fundamental principle of our jurisprudence that no
one can bring an accusation against himself.

Matt. 26:65
Then the high priest tore his clothes, saying, “He has spoken blasphemy!
What further need do we have of witnesses?  Look, now you have heard
His blasphemy!”

Violation No. 8

The charge of blasphemy was only valid if the person
charged had actually pronounced the very Name (the Tetragrammaton
or YHVH) of God.

M:Sanhedrin 7:5
The blasphemer is not guilty until he pronounces the Divine Name expressly.

Violation No. 9

Caiaphas violated the law by accusing Yeshua of blasphemy.  Charges were not to originate with the judges.  They were only to investigate charges brought to them.

Deuteronomy 19:16, 17
If a false witness rises against any man to testify against him of
wrongdoing, then both men in the controversy shall stand before
the Lord, before the priests and the judges who serve in those days.

M;Sanhedrin 7:5
The blasphemer is no guilty unless he pronounces he "Name' (YHVH), the Ineffable Name, expressly.

Violation No. 10

When Caiaphas tore his garments, such action was forbidden on the part of the high priest.

Lev. 21:10
And he who is the high priest among his brethren, on whose head the anointing oil was poured and who is consecrated to wear the garments, shall not uncover his head nor tear his clothes.

Matt. 26:66
“What do you think?”  They answered and said, “He is deserving of death.”

Violation No. 11

The trial did not run for the minimum time period.  Both of Jesus’ trials were completed in the space of less than five hours.  The guilty verdict had to be announced twenty-four hours following the end of the trial.

M:Sanhedrin 4:1
A criminal case resulting in the acquittal of the accused may terminate
the same day on which the trial began.  But if a sentence of death is to
be pronounced, it cannot be concluded before the following day.

Violation No. 12

When the judges together declared that Yeshua was guilty of death, they did it by voice and acclamation.  Voting for a death penalty had to be done on an individual count, beginning with the youngest so that the young would not be influenced by the elder.

M:Sanhedrin 4:8
At each extremity a secretary was placed, whose business was to
record the votes.  One recorded the votes in favor of the accused,
the other of those opposed.

M:Sanhedrin 15:5
Let the judges, each in his turn, absolve or condemn.

Violation No. 13

The verdict of guilty was pronounced at the same time as the trial whereas the law stated that the trial and the guilty verdict had to be separated by at least twenty-four hours.

M:Sanhedrin 4:1
If a sentence of death is to be pronounced, it cannot be concluded
before the following day.

M:Sanhedrin 5:5
If they found for his acquittal, they set him free; if not, they postponed
his sentence until the next day.

Violation No. 14

The law was also violated when the verdict of guilty was given at night and not in the daytime.

M:Sanhedrin 4:1
In capital cases they hold the trial by day and they must come
to a decision during the daytime.

Matt. 26:67
Then they spat in His face and beat Him; and others struck Him
with the palms of their hands.

Violation No. 15

The expression of the judge toward the accused must be humane, and even kind, treating him with gentleness and respect.

Joshua 7:19;  M:Sotah 1:4
This was a principle that was developed by the Sanhedrin in trying a woman that was accused of committing adultery and going through the process known as “Sotah.”  It was a terrible, embarrassing trial for the woman that the Sanhedrin decided that all accused should be treated this way.

Mark 14:53
And they led Jesus away to the high priest; and with Him were assembled all the chief priests, the elders, and the scribes.

Violation No. 16

Sentencing was announced in an unlawful place.  Yeshua’s sentence was pronounced in the high priest’s palace.  It was illegal to sentence anyone to die in any location other than the Great Sanhedrin’s appointed place, which was a chamber on the Temple Mount known as the Chamber of Hewn Stone.

BT:Abodah Zarah 1:8
After leaving the hall Gazith (the Chamber of Hewn Stones) no sentence
of death can be passed upon anyone soever.

Maimonides, Sanhedrin 14
A sentence of death can be pronounced only so long as the Sanhedrin
holds its sessions in the appointed place.

Mark 14:55, 56
And the chief priests and all the council sought testimony against
Jesus to put Him to death, and found none.  For many bore witness
against Him, but their testimonies did not agree.

Violation No. 17

According to the Sanhedrin’s own established procedures, the defense was to be brought forward first and then the accusation.

M:Sanhedrin 4:1
Capital cases must begin with reasons for acquittal and may not
commence with reasons for conviction.

Mark 14:63, 64
Then the high priest tore his clothes and said, “What further need
do we have of witnesses?  You have heard the blasphemy!  What do
you think?”  And they all condemned Him to be deserving of death.

Violation No. 18

Condemnation of Yeshua was unanimous.  All those during the first trial who gathered to hear and judge Yeshua’s case called for the death penalty.

M:Sanhedrin 4:1
In capital cases all may argue for acquittal but not all may argue
for conviction.

John 18:3
Then Judas, having received a detachment of troops, and officers
from the chief priests and Pharisees, came there with lanterns, torches
and weapons.


Violation No. 19

Yeshua’s arrest was planned and carried out at night to conceal evil.  The arrest of Yeshua was set in motion by the chief priests bribing Judas to take them to Yeshua during the night.  However, the law stated that all activity of a capital trial was to be conducted only during the daytime.

M:Sanhedrin 4:1
In capital cases they hold the trial by day and they must come to a
decision during the daytime.

John 18:28
Then they led Jesus from Caiaphas to the Praetorium, and it was early
morning.  But they themselves did not go into the Praetorium, lest they
should be defiled, but that they might eat the Passover.

Violation No. 20

The trial held at night before Caiaphas was over.  They are now taking Yeshua before Pontius Pilate.  The law forbid them to do these things prior to the completion of the morning sacrifice.

M:Sanhedrin 4:1
Let it be tried during the day and be suspended at night.

JT:Sanhedrin 1:9; BT:Sanhedrin 10:88
The Sanhedrin sat from the close of the morning sacrifice to the time
of the evening sacrifice.

Violation No. 21

The trial was held before one of God’s holy days (Passover).  It was illegal based on Jewish law, because it began on a day before one of God’s annual holy day Sabbaths.

M:Sanhedrin 4:1
They shall not judge on the eve of the Sabbath nor on that
of any festival.

M:Betsah 5:2
Court must not be held on the Sabbath, or any holy day.

Mark 14:63, 64
Then the high priest tore his clothes and said, “What further need
do we have of witnesses?  You have heard the blasphemy!  What do
you think?”  And they all condemned Him to be deserving of death.


Violation No. 22

They answered, “He is deserving of death.”  In this one sentence all the other judges agree completely with Caiaphas’ accusation and judgment of blasphemy, instead of first deliberating among themselves, as the law requires.

M:Sanhedrin 5:5
If they found for his acquittal, they set him free; if not, they postpone
his sentence until the next day.  The judges went away in pairs to
discuss the verdict, and they indulged in little food and did not drink
wine all that day, and they discussed the matter thoroughly the whole
night, and rose early the following morning and came to the court.

Matt. 26:65
Then the high priest tore his clothes, saying, “He has spoken
blasphemy!  What further need do we have of witnesses?  Look,
now you have heard His blasphemy!”

Violation No. 23

“He has spoken blasphemy!”  This statement virtually forestalls the decision of the other judges, thus violating the requirement that each of the judges must have the freedom to vote independently, and by a simple “I absolve” or “I condemn.”

M:Sanhedrin 5:5
If they found for his acquittal, they set him free; if not, they postpone
his sentence until the next day.  The judges went away in pairs to
discuss the verdict, and they indulged in little food and did not drink
wine all that day, and they discussed the matter thoroughly the whole
night, and rose early the following morning and came to the court.

Matt. 26:57
And those who laid hold of Jesus led Him away to Caiaphas the
high priest, where the scribes and the elders were assembled.